General Discussion > The Buzz
The 100 greatest rock guitarists
Simon:
...and an alleged pervert. :mmm:
Clive:
Only alleged? I thought he was banged up a couple of times for it?
Simon:
Quite possibly, Clive, but as he's still alive and kicking, I'll let you confirm that. :devil:
GillE:
Richard Thompson at no 142 ??? Sheesh... someone needs to get their priorities sorted out. He's one of the most skillful and innovative guitarists of all time.
Rodders:
I quite agree, Gill! And I thought John Martyn might at least get a mention.
"Criteria: - Guitarists are ranked for their impact, influence, creativity, versatility, originality, technical skill and lasting popularity in the genre of Rock guitar."
On that basis, Hendrix certainly deserves a place near the top - and I can't imagine too many guitarists disagreeing. However, the compilers of this list have made the usual mistake of confusing Fashion with Music. As a result, a number of these artists seem to be included simply because they once appeared on someone's favourite record. I mean... Bo Diddley???
Whilst it's nice to have one's musical taste 'vindicated' by seeing our fave musos published in a list, it would be far more meaningful if professional guitarists were judged by their peers, rather than bedroom air-guitarists. Perhaps then we might see the inclusion of a few more gifted players and a lot less three-chord wonders.
...and while I'm off on one, where's John Scofield and Larry Carlton? :shock:
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version